- Research article
- Open Access
Coal burning-derived SO2 and traffic-derived NO2 are associated with persistent cough and current wheezing symptoms among schoolchildren in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia
Environmental Health and Preventive Medicine volume 24, Article number: 66 (2019)
Children in Ulaanbaatar are exposed to air pollution, but few epidemiological studies have been conducted on the effects of environmental risk factors on children’s health. Also, no studies have yet examined the prevalence of respiratory symptoms in children in suburban areas, where air quality-monitoring stations have not yet been installed. This cross-sectional study evaluated the associations between outdoor air pollution and respiratory symptoms among schoolchildren in urban and suburban districts of Ulaanbaatar.
The ATS-DLD-78 C questionnaire was used to investigate the respiratory symptoms of schoolchildren aged 6–12 years (n = 1190) who lived in one of three urban districts or a suburban district of Ulaanbaatar. In each district, the outdoor concentrations of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and sulfur dioxide (SO2) were measured at two sites (at ≤100 m and > 100 m from the nearest major road) in the 2-year period from 2015 to 2016. The associations between health outcomes and exposure to air pollutants were estimated using the multinomial logistic regression method.
The outdoor concentration of SO2 was significantly associated with persistent cough symptom (OR = 1.12, 95% CI 1.04–1.22). Furthermore, the outdoor concentration of NO2 was significantly associated with the current wheezing symptom (OR = 1.33, 95% CI 1.01–1.75) among children in urban and suburban.
The prevalence of persistent cough symptom was markedly high among the schoolchildren in urban/suburban districts of Ulaanbaatar. Overall, the increases in the prevalence of respiratory symptoms among children might be associated with ambient air pollution in Ulaanbaatar.
Ulaanbaatar is the capital city of Mongolia, and it is located in a basin surrounded by four mountains. Its geographical location and cold climate make it highly susceptible to environmental pollution. For example, temperature inversion layers can trap cold air in such basins, which makes it less likely that air pollutants will diffuse . The current population of Ulaanbaatar is 1.3 million, which represents > 45% of Mongolia’s population. Ulaanbaatar has a relatively young population, with approximately 30.1% of the total population aged < 15 years .
Currently, Ulaanbaatar is one of the most polluted cities in the world [3,4,5]. The city has expanded considerably due to internal migration, and much of the population lives on the outskirts of the city in traditional nomadic dwellings (gers). In “gers”, raw coal is still used for heating and cooking, and the mean amounts of coal and wood used per year in Ulaanbaatar are 5 tons and 3 m3, respectively . Significant internal immigration from rural areas of Mongolia to Ulaanbaatar has occurred in recent decades . Urbanization has played a major role in increasing air pollution in the city, as it has resulted in population growth, the expansion of areas containing lots of “gers”, and marked increases in the number of vehicles and traffic jams. The number of vehicles has increased rapidly from 75,000 vehicles in 2005 to 300,000 vehicles in 2014 . Significant effects of air pollution and seasonality on health-related quality of life have been detected in adult patients with bronchial asthma, and the morbidity rate of respiratory diseases increased by 44.8% from 2004 to 2008  . Also, 9.7% of total deaths, 29% of cardiopulmonary deaths, and 40% of lung cancer deaths in Ulaanbaatar in 2009 were caused by air pollution .
Various adverse effects of outdoor air pollution on children’s respiratory health have been identified. It has been reported that exposure to air pollutants significantly increases the incidence of respiratory symptoms in children [8,9,10,11,12]. Mongolian children are more exposed to air pollution than children living in other countries. However, few epidemiological studies on the effects of environmental risk factors on children’s health in Mongolia have been conducted . Previous studies found correlations between ambient air pollutant levels and spontaneous abortion in Ulaanbaatar . Furthermore, the increased concentrations of sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) have been reported to be associated with lower baby weights . Mongolian children’s urinary 1-hydroxypyrene (1-OHP) levels were reported to be associated with the ambient air concentrations of the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon co-pollutants SO2 and NO2, and it was suggested that the increased urinary 1-OHP levels exhibited by Mongolian children might be attributed to PAH emissions from coal burning and traffic . Regarding the respiratory health effects of urban and rural environments on children, changes in the concentrations of air pollutants and the household use of solid fuel have been found to be associated with fatal or non-fatal respiratory diseases, airway narrowing, or a slower rate of forced vital capacity growth [17, 18].
Therefore, this study evaluated the associations between outdoor air pollution and respiratory symptoms among schoolchildren in urban and suburban areas of Ulaanbaatar.
We used a cross-sectional study design to investigate the effects of short-term outdoor exposure to NO2 and SO2 on the respiratory symptoms of children during the 2-year period from 2015 to 2016.
Participants and residential areas
The participants were 1200 children (age 6–12 years) from five public elementary schools. The schools were located in three urban districts (Sukhbaatar, Khan-Uul, and Bayanzurkh) and a suburban district (Nalaikh) in Ulaanbaatar. The districts were named A, B, C, and D, respectively. Figure 1 shows the locations of the study areas in Ulaanbaatar. District A is located in the center of the city. Two public schools in district A were included in this study. District B is located adjacent to district A, and industrial activity takes place in this district. District C is located at the eastern end of the urban area, and most residents live in “gers”. For comparative analysis, we selected suburban area D, which is located 40 km southeast of the urban area. It is the nearest suburban area to the capital and has increased rapidly in size, as internal migrants have moved from rural areas; therefore, approximately 70% of the residents live in “gers”.
In each of these districts, the targeted school was close to traffic major road within 200 m. In the urban areas, outdoor air pollutant levels were measured by ambient air quality-monitoring stations. However, such systems have not yet been installed in district D (the suburban area; Fig. 1).
Distance from each subject’s residence to the nearest major road and traffic volume
We estimated the distance between each subject’s residence and the nearest major road using the GeoNET 9.7.107 GPS navigator for mobile mapping software. Then, we categorized the subjects into ≤ 100 m and > 100 m groups, depending on the distance from their residence to the nearest major road. Also, we measured the daily traffic volume at the major road nearest to each school four times in 2015. The mean daily traffic volume was determined using a vehicle counter (Tempomat CRM, IV, Radarlux).
The survey about respiratory symptoms was based on a questionnaire adapted from the American Thoracic Society Epidemiologic Standardization Project questionnaire ; i.e., the ATS DLD 78 C questionnaire for children, which has been used in previous studies [8, 20,21,22,23,24]. The questionnaire was translated into Mongolian and then distributed to the participants via their schools. It was completed by their parents at home after obtaining written parental consent. The participants were given a week to return the questionnaire. All of the questionnaires were given ID numbers prior to the analysis.
The items included in the questionnaire were age, sex, residential address, whether the subject was bottle-fed in infancy, how long they had lived at their current residence, the heating system used in their home, their parents’ smoking habits at home, and their history of respiratory disease and current respiratory symptom status. The questionnaire covered the following respiratory symptoms: persistent cough, persistent phlegm, current wheezing, and asthma-like symptom. Respiratory symptoms were recorded as being present if a participant answered, “Yes”, to a relevant question. The participants were provided with explanations about each respiratory symptom [see Additional file 1: Table S1].
Passive sampling of air pollutants near schools
We selected NO2 and SO2 as indicators of outdoor air pollution. The ambient air concentrations of NO2 and SO2 were measured near the schools. The concentrations of these pollutants were measured in February, April, August, and November in 2015 and in January, April, July, and October in 2016. The two field blanks used for the concentration analysis and the filters for NO2 and SO2 were exchanged five times each at intervals of approximately 48 h. The samplers were installed for 10 days (14,400 ± 5 min). We measured the mean air temperature and relative humidity during the same period as the NO2 and SO2 measurements were obtained. The levels of NO2 and SO2 were assessed using co-located Ogawa passive samplers (Ogawa & Co., Ltd., Kobe, Japan), which were used in previous studies [4, 25,26,27,28]. The passive samplers were installed at two sites, which were located ≤ 100 m and > 100 m from the nearest major road, respectively, at a height of approximately 2.5 m.
All statistical analyses were performed using the PASW Statistics software, v.18 (Chicago, IL, USA). All questionnaire data were analyzed based on the ID numbers assigned to the questionnaires. The associations between respiratory symptoms and personal and environmental factors were analyzed statistically via multinomial logistic regression analysis. The respiratory symptoms were used as dependent variables, and potential confounding factors were used as independent variables. The following variables were considered to be potential confounding factors: gender, age, how long the subject had lived at their current residence (years), history of asthma diagnosed by a doctor, history of allergies or respiratory disease before the age of 2 years, history of pneumonia, being bottle-fed in infancy, parental smoking habits, and the distance between the subject’s residence and the nearest major road. We also analyzed the associations between the concentrations of air pollutants and respiratory symptoms; i.e., logistic regression was used to calculate odds ratio (OR) and 95% confidence interval (CI) values. P-values of < 0.05 (two-tailed) were considered statistically significant. Adjusted OR were estimated and scaled to represent a 1-ppb increase in the NO2 or SO2 concentration, based on the mean 2-year concentrations and traffic volume data for each district. The paired t-test was used to examine the significance of differences in the seasonal concentrations of SO2 and NO2, and changes in the NO2 concentration due to the distance from the main road. We evaluated the statistical significance of differences in the frequency of respiratory symptoms between the residential areas using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). P-values of < 0.05 (two-tailed) were considered to be statistically significant.
Analytical method for NO2
The NO2 collection filters (14.5 mmφ) were placed in 25-ml glass vials. Then, 8 ml distilled water was added to the filter-containing vials, and each vial was subjected to shaking for extraction. After 30 min of extraction, the vials were refrigerated at 4–5 °C for 30 min. Then, 2 ml of sulfanilamide solution and 1-naphthyl-ethylenediamine dihydrochloride (NEDA; 0.56 g dissolved in 100 ml distilled water, stored at − 4 °C) solution were added in a 10:1 ratio. The resultant mixture was simultaneously shaken and cooled for 30 min. After that, the vials were returned to room temperature. The absorbance of the samples was determined with a spectrophotometer at a wavelength of 545 nm.
Analytical method for SO2
Filter papers were put in 25-ml glass vials containing 8 ml distilled water. Then, the vials were shaken for extraction for about 30 min, before the filter papers were collected. Next, hydrogen peroxide solution (H2O2, 1.75%) was added, and the vials were shaken slowly for 10 min, before the mixture was equilibrated at room temperature and analyzed using ion chromatography. SO2 concentrations were analyzed via ion chromatography at the laboratory of Ogawa & Co., Ltd. (Kobe, Japan). The same procedure was used for all blank samples and standard solutions. We calculated the ambient concentrations of NO2 and SO2 using the following equations:
αNO2, αSO2: ppb concentration conversion coefficient (ppb min/ng).
W NO2: quantity (ng) collected in NO2 collection elements.
W SO2: quantity (ng) collected in SO2 collection elements.
T: exposure time (min).
αNO2 was calculated based on the temperature, humidity, and exposure time during the measurement period. We used meteorological data from the private Weather Underground Station Network, which directly collects data from weather stations around the world . The abovementioned analytical methods for NO2 and SO2 concentrations were based on the Ogawa protocol.
Pollutant exposure assessment
During the measurement period, the mean daily temperatures varied among the seasons. In winter (February 2015 and January 2016), spring (April 2015 and 2016), summer (August 2015 and July 2016), and fall (November 2015 and October 2016), the mean daily temperature was − 22.1 °C, 8.5 °C, 22.0 °C, and − 8.2 °C and the mean relative humidity value was 65%, 35%, 52%, and 54%, respectively. Table 1 summarizes the distribution of mean air pollutant concentrations in the four districts of Ulaanbaatar during the 2-year period from 2015 to 2016. In each study area, the concentrations of SO2 and NO2 exceeded the ambient air quality standard values for Mongolia [annual mean concentration of SO2: 10 μg/m3 (3.8 ppb), annual mean concentration of NO2: 30 μg/m3 (16 ppb); MNS 4585:2007]. In districts A–D, the 2-year mean concentrations of SO2 were 5.2 ppb, 4.4 ppb, 10.1 ppb, and 7.1 ppb, respectively, and the maximum concentrations of SO2 were 36 ppb, 39 ppb, 63 ppb, and 46 ppb, respectively. The minimum concentration of SO2 was 0.0 ppb in each district. Higher SO2 concentrations were detected in districts C and D than in districts A and B.
For NO2, the mean annual concentration was 30.0 ppb, 27.7 ppb, 30.0 ppb, and 18.2 ppb in districts A–D, respectively, and the maximum concentrations were 86 ppb, 74 ppb, 99 ppb, and 68 ppb, respectively. Higher NO2 concentration were detected in districts A, B, and C than in district D. Figure 2 shows seasonal comparisons of outdoor SO2 concentrations between the four districts. High SO2 concentrations were detected in each district in January and February. During this period, the mean SO2 concentration was 14.3 ± 9.0 ppb, 12.3 ± 10.2 ppb, 21.9 ± 10.3 ppb, and 19.6 ± 11.6 ppb in districts A–D, respectively. There were significant differences in the SO2 concentration between each district, except between districts A and B (p < 0.01) [see Additional file 1: Table S3]. In April, the mean SO2 concentrations in each district were roughly similar (the mean SO2 concentrations of districts A–D decreased to 2.0 ± 1.5 ppb, 3.0 ± 1.9 ppb, 2.6 ± 1.8 ppb, and 2.1 ± 3.2 ppb, respectively). Only the SO2 concentrations of districts A and B differed significantly (p < 0.05). In August, the mean SO2 concentration decreased to 1.0 ppb in each district. However, in November, the mean SO2 concentration increased again to 5.0 ± 2.5 ppb, 2.9 ± 1.7 ppb, 9.6 ± 8.3 ppb, and 8.0 ± 4.6 ppb in districts A–D, respectively. There were significant differences between the SO2 concentrations of all districts, except for between the SO2 concentrations of districts C and D.
The results indicated that in all districts, the mean NO2 concentration exceeded the ambient air quality standard value in all months, except for August. Figure 3 shows a seasonal comparison of outdoor NO2 concentrations between the districts. The concentration of NO2 was high in each district in February, especially in the urban districts (A, B, and C). The mean NO2 concentration was 54.6 ± 17.1 ppb, 48.1 ± 15.1 ppb, 56.3 ± 21.4 ppb, and 40.5 ± 14.1 ppb in districts A–D, respectively. There were significant differences between the NO2 concentrations of all districts, except for between those of districts A and C (p < 0.01) [see Additional file 1: Table S4].
In April, the mean NO2 concentration decreased to 20.0 ± 3.9 ppb, 21.6 ± 5.4 ppb, 17.5 ± 7.3 ppb, and 9.1 ± 1.9 ppb in districts A–D, respectively. There were significant differences between the NO2 concentrations of each district except for between those for districts A and B, and districts A and C (p < 0.01). In August, the mean NO2 concentrations of the three urban districts were roughly similar and had decreased to 16.5 ± 3.8 ppb, 16.5 ± 6.0 ppb, 16.9 ± 7.4 ppb, and 6.1 ± 1.8 ppb, respectively. The mean NO2 concentration of district D differed significantly from those of districts A, B, and C (p < 0.000). However, the mean NO2 concentration of each district increased again in November. The mean NO2 concentration was 28.7 ± 8.5 ppb, 24.7 ± 9.2 ppb, 28.7 ± 8.0 ppb, and 17.4 ± 8.1 ppb in districts A–D, respectively. There were significant differences between the mean NO2 concentrations of all districts, except between those of districts A and C (p < 0.01). In all districts, the mean NO2 concentration in each season exceeded the ambient air quality standard value (except for the NO2 concentrations of district D in April and August, Fig. 3).
In addition, in each district we examined the NO2 concentrations detected at sites located ≤ 100 m and > 100 m from the nearest major road (hereafter referred to as the ≤ 100 m and > 100 m sites). Table 2 shows the differences in the NO2 concentration depending on the distance from the nearest major road. In districts A, B, and C, significantly higher NO2 concentrations were detected at the ≤ 100 m sites than at the > 100 m sites. The mean values obtained for the ≤ 100 m and > 100 m sites in each district were as follows: district A, 31.8 ppb vs. 29.1 ppb (p < 0.05); district B, 34 ppb vs. 23 ppb (p < 0.01); and district C, 33 ppb vs. 27 ppb (p < 0.01), respectively. However, there were no significant differences between the values obtained for the ≤ 100 m and > 100 m sites in the suburban district (district D) (17.5 ppb vs. 17.8 ppb; p < 0.15).
Mapping software was used to determine the location of each subject’s residence based on their home address, and the distance between each subject’s home and the nearest major road was manually determined for all participants [see Additional file 1: Figure S1]. All elementary schools were located within 200 m of the nearest major road. In the urban districts (A, B, and C), the examined major roads had 2–3 times higher traffic volumes than the major road in the suburban district. The mean ± standard deviation daily traffic volume was 16,842 ± 2211, 16,985 ± 1788, 19,473 ± 2686, and 7187 ± 736 vehicles in districts A–D, respectively.
Prevalence of respiratory symptoms among children
The survey was carried out in 2015. The questionnaire was completed by 1130 children, and 21 children were excluded because they were living in other districts or did not fill out more than half of the questionnaire. Table 3 shows the personal and environmental data obtained via the questionnaire alongside the prevalence of respiratory symptoms by district. The ATS DLD questionnaire was correctly completed by 1109 (92.4%) participants. Among the subjects aged 6–12 years, the most common respiratory symptom was persistent cough (28.5%). In addition, 20.2% of the subjects reported persistent phlegm, 5.8% had current wheezing, and 0.7% reported asthma-like symptom. Furthermore, the following findings were obtained regarding the frequency of other background factors: being bottle-fed in infancy: 18.4%, a history of respiratory disease before the age of 2 years: 26%, a history of diagnosed asthma: 2.4%, a history of diagnosed pneumonia: 6.2%, history of residence year for > 3 years: 65.6%, parents smoke at home: 43.1%, coal being used for heating at home: 33.5%, and living ≤ 100 m from the nearest major road: 37.4%. In particular, in districts C and D, high prevalence of subjects had persistent cough (32% and 37%, respectively). However, the prevalence of asthma-like symptoms was low.
Associations between exposure to outdoor air pollution and respiratory symptoms
Table 4 shows the associations between the outdoor SO2 or NO2 concentration and the prevalence of respiratory symptoms identified using a logistic regression model adjusted for confounding variables (n = 1109). Persistent cough was associated with the outdoor concentration of SO2 (OR 1.12, 95% CI 1.04–1.22; per 1 ppb increase), whereas current wheezing was associated with the NO2 concentration (OR 1.33, 95% CI 1.01–1.75). Conversely, no statistically significant associations were found between the outdoor SO2 or NO2 concentration and other symptoms. Also, traffic volume was not associated with respiratory symptoms, such as with persistent cough (OR 0.87, 95% CI 0.73–1.03), persistent phlegm (OR 0.95, 95% CI 0.80–1.14), or current wheezing (OR 0.77, 95% CI 0.58–1.03). The associations between personal or environmental factors and respiratory symptoms were examined using multinomial regression analysis. Current wheezing was found to be significantly associated with being bottle-fed in infancy (OR 2.04, 95% CI 1.14–3.66), and persistent phlegm was demonstrated to be associated with a history of respiratory disease before the age of 2 years (OR 1.58, 95% CI 1.10–2.25). Also, a history of pneumonia was shown to be associated with persistent phlegm (OR 1.90, 95% CI 1.07–3.36) and current wheezing (OR 4.01, 95% CI 1.87–8.60) [see Additional file 1: Table S5]. Furthermore, the prevalence of persistent cough was significantly increased among the children that lived within 100 m of a major road (OR 1.86, 95% CI 1.37–2.51). However, we could not analyze the associations between current asthma-like symptom and confounding factors, as the prevalence of this condition was very low.
In the present study, the mean concentrations of SO2 and NO2 exceeded the Mongolian ambient air quality standards in each district, excluding the NO2 concentration in the suburban district. The concentrations of both pollutants peaked during winter (maximum concentrations: 36 ppb to 63 ppb for SO2 and 74 ppb to 99 ppb for NO2, Table 1). Ulaanbaatar city is located in a basin. In winter, a phenomenon called a temperature inversion layer can arise in basins, which reduces the diffusion of air pollutants . In a previous study, the annual mean concentration of SO2 in an urban area of Ulaanbaatar was reported to be 12.35 ± 14.53 μg/m3 (4.71 ppb) . In our study, the mean concentration of SO2 in the three urban districts (A, B, and C) was 6.5 ± 10.3 ppb, and district C, which contains many gers dwelling, exhibited the highest mean SO2 concentration. Also, the mean SO2 concentration was higher in the districts with large numbers of gers (districts C and D; mean SO2 concentrations: 10.1 ppb and 7.1 ppb, respectively) than in the areas that contain lots of apartments (districts A and B; mean SO2 concentrations: 5.2 ppb and 4.4 ppb, respectively). Previous studies have detected differences in the mean SO2 concentration between “gers” and “non-gers” sites in Ulaanbaatar [28, 31]. A 2011 survey reported a higher mean SO2 concentration for “gers” areas (46.60 ppb) than for “non-gers” areas (23.35 ppb) . This can be partly explained by the fact that the 2011 census showed that the population of Ulaanbaatar had increased by 300,000 from 2000 to 2008. Simultaneously, the numbers of residents living in “gers” districts have increased rapidly as a result of internal immigration; i.e., from rural areas to the capital city . In 2010, a study reported that in winter the NO2 and SO2 concentrations in the urban areas of Ulaanbaatar were 10.7 ± 5.8 ppb and 17 ± 11.8 ppb, respectively . In the present study, the mean concentrations of NO2 and SO2 in the three urban districts (A, B, and C) were 53.0 ± 8.1 ppb and 18.7 ± 15.0 ppb, respectively, in winter. The urban districts (A, B, and C; 30.0 ppb, 27.7 ppb, and 30.0 ppb, respectively) had higher mean NO2 concentrations than the suburban district D (18.2 ppb). The concentrations for the urban districts were 2–3-fold higher than those obtained in the abovementioned study. The reason for this is that the number of vehicles in Ulaanbaatar doubled from 2010 to 2015, and the mean vehicle speed on Ulaanbaatar’s major roads has decreased from approximately 40 km/h to 20 km/h [33, 34]. Due to the poor dispersal conditions encountered in winter, it is assumed that vehicle exhaust emissions accumulate within the city in winter.
NO2 is used as a marker of traffic-related pollutant because its concentration peaks close to roadways, but decreases to background levels by about 200 m from the nearest major road [25, 35, 36]. A previous study reported that the NO2 concentration was approximately 5 ppb higher at the roadside than at other urban sites in Ulaanbaatar . In our study, the difference in the NO2 concentration between the roadside and non-roadside sites was about 3–10 ppb in the urban districts (A, B, and C). Also, the NO2 concentration was lower at the sites located > 100 m from the nearest major road than at those located ≤ 100 m from the nearest major road. This result is consistent with our findings regarding traffic volume. Traffic volume was significantly higher in the urban districts (A, B, and C) than in the suburban area (district D). The fact that the concentration of NO2 decreases away from major traffic, roads can be considered to be due to the effects of automobile exhaust gas [28, 36]. Central urban areas include many bus routes and experience numerous traffic jams. Due to traffic congestion, vehicles have to slow down, which is considered to increase NO2 emissions. In winter, the temperature outside is cold, so drivers gradually move forward with their engines on. Currently, no surveys in Mongolia have directly measured exhaust gas emissions from vehicles.
Respiratory health outcomes
This study confirmed that Mongolian schoolchildren have high prevalence rates of persistent cough (28.5%), persistent phlegm production (20.2%), current wheezing (5.8%), and asthma-like symptoms (0.7%). When the prevalence was examined by district, the prevalence of persistent cough was high in the suburban compared to the urban district which has similar many gers dwellings (37% vs. 32%, respectively). Conversely, the concentration of SO2 was higher in district C than in the suburban (district D). The survey indicated that there are several possible reasons for this first, more children in district D (72%) than in district C (47%) lived in a household in which coal was used. So, it is considered that these children were affected by emissions from coal. Another possible reason is that the children in district D had lived in the same place for a longer period than those in district C; i.e., 74% of the children in district D had lived in the same residence place for > 3 years, whereas the equivalent figure for district C was 62% (data shown in Table 3). In a previous study, in which the subjects had a similar age distribution to those in our study, it was concluded that outdoor air pollution is the major source of black carbon (BC) and fine particulate matter (PM2.5) exposure for children living in Ulaanbaatar. Also, it was reported that the children living in a district containing many “gers” were exposed to the highest levels of outdoor air pollution . In our study, persistent cough was significantly more common in the areas containing many “gers” (districts C and D) than in the areas containing large numbers of apartments (districts A and B, p < 0.001) [see Additional file 1: Table S6]. In particular, the prevalence rate of persistent cough was significantly higher in the suburban district (district D) than in the urban areas (districts A, B, and C, p < 0.000). Even in the suburbs, the use of coal has led to a high prevalence of persistent cough in children. We were reported that on an isolated island without major artificial sources of air pollutants, changes in the concentrations of air pollutants acutely influenced the pulmonary function of healthy subjects . On the other hand, the increased prevalence of respiratory symptoms may also affect the burning of solid waste at the open dumpsites in the gers districts. There still has a problem with solid waste, coal ash and other rubbish, and also low-income households burn old tires, plastic bottles [39, 40]. Das B et al. reported that open burning of municipal solid waste is a poorly characterized and frequently underestimated source of air pollution. It is can trigger health impacts such as acute and chronic respiratory disease . Boadi K. O et al. reported also that inadequate solid waste facilities result in indiscriminate burning and burying of solid waste. There is an association between waste burning and the incidence of respiratory health symptoms among children .
In the statistical analysis, we confirmed that the prevalence of persistent cough among children was associated with the concentration of SO2. Some Chinese studies have reported that children exhibit enhanced sensitivity to the harmful effects of air pollution. In addition, it was confirmed that genetic susceptibility and/or exposure to common environmental factors have a strong influence on respiratory health [8, 43].
In our study, the current wheezing symptom among children associated an increase in NO2 concentration (data shown in Table 4). Nicolai T et al.reported that the frequency of current wheezing among children increased with the NO2 concentration . Also, in our study, the children who were bottle-fed in infancy displayed an increased prevalence of current wheezing. Other studies have demonstrated that being breastfed was associated with a lower risk of lung function problems and reduced children’s susceptibility to the respiratory effects of pollutants [45, 46].
The prevalence of persistent cough and phlegm were reported to be more common among children in Mongolia than among children in the north and north-eastern cities of China and Thailand, but the frequencies of current wheezing and asthma-like symptom were similar in all of these places [8, 21, 22, 43]. It is considered that other than the geographical features mentioned above and the temperature inversion layer phenomenon that occurs in winter, meteorological features also have a great influence, as Ulaanbaatar has a longer heating period than China; i.e., it lasts for 8 months from mid-September to mid-May . In winter, when coal consumption increases, the concentrations of air pollutants are expected to rise markedly, which might induce respiratory symptoms in children. However, a previous Japanese study found that persistent cough and phlegm were less common among Japanese children than among Mongolian children, although current wheezing and asthma-like symptom were more common among Japanese children . One possible reason for this is that since the 1970s, the atmospheric concentration of SO2 in Japan has reduced owing to the introduction of emission-control technologies. On the other hand, NO2 concentrations decreased from 1970 to 1985, but increased from 1985 to 1995. NO2 concentrations are notably higher at roadside air-monitoring stations .
Highlights of this study
We conducted a survey of respiratory symptoms among children and measured the air pollution levels in Ulaanbaatar, including in a suburban area. No previous studies have examined the prevalence of respiratory symptoms among children in suburban areas. Furthermore, outdoor air pollutants were being measured at ambient air quality monitoring stations in the urban areas of Ulaanbaatar. However, such systems have not been installed in the suburban areas surrounding the city. Moreover, traffic volume was assessed in a suburban area for the first time in this study.
Limitations of this study
In this study, we only measured the levels of NO2 and SO2. The obtained SO2 concentrations were lower than those obtained via national air quality monitoring because they were measured at sites located within 200 m of major roads. Also, this study did not measure the levels of particulate matter, and the personal exposure levels of each subject were not evaluated. In addition, this study did not use continuous monitoring data, and the measurement of air pollutants was conducted over a short period of time. The concentrations of air toxins, such as diesel exhaust particles or surrogates, such as black carbon or soot, should be more widely monitored.
This study investigated the effects of short-term outdoor air pollution exposure on the respiratory symptoms of children in Ulaanbaatar. The prevalence of persistent cough symptom was high among schoolchildren in urban and suburban districts of Ulaanbaatar. The outdoor SO2 concentration was associated with the persistent cough symptom, and the NO2 concentration was associated with the current wheezing symptom among children. We also found that living near a major road results in children being exposed to traffic-related air pollution, which could aid future epidemiological studies. A study of air pollution control in suburban areas is necessary to promote public health.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
American Thoracic Society Division of Lung Disease
- NO2 :
- SO2 :
Amarsaikhan D, Battsengel V, Nergui B, Ganzorig M, Bolor G. A study on air pollution in Ulaanbaatar City, Mongolia. J Geosci Environ Protection. 2014;02:123–8. https://doi.org/10.4236/gep.2014.22017.
National Statistical Office of Mongolia. Statistical yearbook for Ulaanbaatar city. 2015.
WHO. Ambient (outdoor) air pollution database, by country and city. 2016.
Allen RW, Gombojav E, Barkhasragchaa B, Byambaa T, Lkhasuren O, Amram O, et al. An assessment of air pollution and its attributable mortality in Ulaanbaatar. Mongolia Air Qual Atmos Health. 2013;6:137–50. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11869-011-0154-3.
Hirano A. Remote sensing and GIS approach for capturing herders indigenous knowledge of selecting suitable areas for winter camp locations in Mongolia. Asian conference on remote sensing, vol. 33; 2012.
Guttikunda SK. Urban air pollution analysis for Ulaanbaatar; 2008.
Saijaa N, Oyunbileg J, Palam, Enkhutya, Kupul, . Air pollution and health Ulaanbaatar. ISEE 22nd Annual Conference. 2011.
Pan G, Zhang S, Feng Y, Takahashi K, Kagawa J, Yu L, et al. Air pollution and children's respiratory symptoms in six cities of northern China. Respir Med. 2010;104:1903–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rmed.2010.07.018.
Rodriguez-Villamizar LA, Magico A, Osornio-Vargas A, Rowe BH. The effects of outdoor air pollution on the respiratory health of Canadian children: a systematic review of epidemiological studies. Can Respir J. 2015;22:282–92. https://doi.org/10.1155/2015/263427.
Mentz G, Robins TG, Batterman S, Naidoo RN. Acute respiratory symptoms associated with short term fluctuations in ambient pollutants among schoolchildren in Durban. South Africa Environ Pollut. 2018;233:529–39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2017.10.108.
Moon JS, Kim YS, Kim JH, Son BS, Kim DS, Yang W. Respiratory health effects among schoolchildren and their relationship to air pollutants in Korea. Int J Environ Health Res. 2009;19:31–48. https://doi.org/10.1080/09603120802272201.
Velicka H, Puklova V, Keder J, Brabec M, Maly M, Bobak M, et al. Asthma exacerbations and symptom variability in children due to short-term ambient air pollution changes in Ostrava, Czech Republic. Cent Eur J Public Health. 2015;23:292–8. https://doi.org/10.21101/cejph.a4548.
Jadambaa A, Spickett J, Badrakh B, Norman RE. The impact of the environment on health in Mongolia: a systematic review. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2015;27:45–75. https://doi.org/10.1177/1010539514545648.
Enkhmaa D, Warburton N, Javzandulam B, Uyanga J, Khishigsuren Y, Lodoysamba S, et al. Seasonal ambient air pollution correlates strongly with spontaneous abortion in Mongolia. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2014;14:146. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2393-14-146.
Dorj G, Dayan A, Nanjid K, Lkhagvaa U, Оchir C. Is air pollution a risk factor for low birth weight in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia? OALib. 2014;01:1–6. https://doi.org/10.4236/oalib.1100885.
Chen YT, Huang YK, Luvsan ME, Gombojav E, Ochir C, Bulgan J, et al. The influence of season and living environment on children's urinary 1-hydroxypyrene levels in Ulaanbaatar. Mongolia Environ Res. 2015;137:170–5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2014.11.022.
Priftis KN, Anthracopoulos MB, Paliatsos AG, Tzavelas G, Nikolaou-Papanagiotou A, Douridas P, et al. Different effects of urban and rural environments in the respiratory status of Greek schoolchildren. Respir Med. 2007;101:98–106. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rmed.2006.04.008.
Hystad P, Duong M, Brauer M, Larkin A, Arku R, Kurmi OP, et al. Health effects of household solid fuel use: findings from 11 countries within the prospective urban and rural epidemiology study. Environ Health Perspect. 2019;127:57003. https://doi.org/10.1289/ehp3915.
Ferris BG. Epidemiology standardization project (American Thoracic Society). Am Rev Respir Dis. 1978;118:1–120.
Hasunuma H, Sato T, Iwata T, Kohno Y, Nitta H, Odajima H, et al. Association between traffic-related air pollution and asthma in preschool children in a national Japanese nested case-control study. BMJ Open. 2016;6:e010410. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2015-010410.
Langkulsen U, Jinsart W, Karita K, Yano E. Respiratory symptoms and lung function in Bangkok school children. Eur J Pub Health. 2006;16:676–81. https://doi.org/10.1093/eurpub/ckl061.
Kagawa J, Nohara M, Pan G, C-y Q, Yang ZM. Comparison of respiratory symptoms between schoolchildren in China and Japan. Allergol Int. 2001;50:303–9. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1440-1592.2001.00231.x.
Jaakkola JJ, Parise H, Kislitsin V, Lebedeva NI, Spengler JD. Asthma, wheezing, and allergies in Russian schoolchildren in relation to new surface materials in the home. Am J Public Health. 2004;94:560–2.
Shima M, Adachi M. Effect of outdoor and indoor nitrogen dioxide on respiratory symptoms in schoolchildren. Int J Epidemiol. 2000;29:862–70.
Gilbert NL, Woodhouse S, Stieb DM, Brook JR. Ambient nitrogen dioxide and distance from a major highway. Sci Total Environ. 2003;312:43–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0048-9697(03)00228-6.
Stuart AL, Zeager M. An inequality study of ambient nitrogen dioxide and traffic levels near elementary schools in the Tampa area. J Environ Manag. 2011;92:1923–30. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2011.03.003.
Hagenbjork-Gustafsson A, Tornevi A, Forsberg B, Eriksson K. Field validation of the Ogawa diffusive sampler for NO2 and NOx in a cold climate. J Environ Monit. 2010;12:1315–24. https://doi.org/10.1039/b924615k.
Huang YK, Luvsan ME, Gombojav E, Ochir C, Bulgan J, Chan CC. Land use patterns and SO2 and NO2 pollution in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. Environ Res. 2013;124:1–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2013.02.006.
Weather Underground (WU) . https://www.wunderground.com/.
Gantuya G, Jong JB. Local circulations in and around the Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia, metropolitan area. Meteorog Atmos Phys. 2015;127:493–6.
Munkh-Erdene L, Ruei-Hao S, Tseden P, Badarch L, Baldorj B, Chang-Chuan C. The influence of emission sources and meteorological conditions on SO2 pollution in Mongolia. Atmos Environ. 2012;61:542–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.atmosenv.2012.07.044.
Chilkhaasuren B, Baasankhuu B. Population and economic activities of Ulaanbaatar; 2012.
Tsevegjav N. Urban transport system in Ulaanbaatar city. In: Sustainable and Inclusive Transport Development; 2014.
Dorjkhand B, Miki M. A Study on Bus Transportation Service in Ulaanbaatar City. International Conference of Asian-Pacific Planing Societies; 2017.
Shima M, Adachi M. Indoor nitrogen dioxide in homes along trunk roads with heavy traffic. Occup Environ Med. 1998;55:428–33.
Luther Smith SM. Kasey Kovalcik, Elizabeth Sams, Casson Stallings. Near-road measurements for nitrogen dioxide and its association with traffic exposure zones. Atmospheric Poll Res. 2015;6:1082–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apr.2015.06.005.
Dashnyam U, Warburton N, Brugha R, Tserenkh I, Davaasambuu E, Enkhtur S, et al. Personal exposure to fine-particle black carbon air pollution among schoolchildren living in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. Central Asian J Med Sci. 2015;1:67–74.
Yoda Y, Takagi H, Wakamatsu J, Ito T, Nakatsubo R, Horie Y, et al. Acute effects of air pollutants on pulmonary function among students: a panel study in an isolated island. Environ Health Prev Med. 2017;22:33. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12199-017-0646-3.
JICA. The study on solid waste management plan for Ulaanbaatar City in Mongolia. 2007.
Delgermaa G, Matsumoto T. A study of waste Management of Households in Ulaanbaatar based on questionnaire surveys. Int J Environ Sci Dev. 2016;7:368–71. https://doi.org/10.7763/ijesd.2016.v7.802.
Das B, Bhave PV, Sapkota A, Byanju RM. Estimating emissions from open burning of municipal solid waste in municipalities of Nepal. Waste Manag. 2018;79:481–90. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2018.08.013.
Boadi KO, Kuitunen M. Environmental and health impacts of household solid waste handling and disposal practices in third world cities: the case of the Accra metropolitan area, Ghana. J Environ Health. 2005;68:32–6.
Liu F, Zhao Y, Liu YQ, Liu Y, Sun J, Huang MM, et al. Asthma and asthma related symptoms in 23,326 Chinese children in relation to indoor and outdoor environmental factors: the Seven Northeastern Cities (SNEC) Study. Sci Total Environ. 2014;497–498:10–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2014.07.096.
Nicolai T, Carr D, Weiland SK, Duhme H, von Ehrenstein O, Wagner C, et al. Urban traffic and pollutant exposure related to respiratory outcomes and atopy in a large sample of children. Eur Respir J. 2003;21:956–63. https://doi.org/10.1183/09031936.03.00041103a.
Dong GH, Qian ZM, Liu MM, Wang D, Ren WH, Bawa S, et al. Breastfeeding as a modifier of the respiratory effects of air pollution in children. Epidemiology. 2013;24:387–94. https://doi.org/10.1097/EDE.0b013e3182877eb8.
Zhang C, Guo Y, Xiao X, Bloom MS, Qian Z, Rolling CA, et al. Association of breastfeeding and air pollution exposure with lung function in Chinese children. JAMA Netw Open. 2019;2:e194186. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.4186.
Kamata T, Reichert JA, Tsevegmid T, Kim Y, Sedgewick B. Managing urban expansion in Mongolia:best Practicces in Snenario-based urban planning; 2010.
Wakamatsu S, Morikawa T, Ito A. Air pollution trends in Japan between 1970 and 2012 and impact of urban air pollution countermeasures. Asian J Atmospheric Environ. 2013;7:177–90. https://doi.org/10.5572/ajae.2013.7.4.177.
We are grateful to the teachers and parents of the schoolchildren for their cooperation and support. Traffic volume was assessed in cooperation with the Ulaanbaatar Intelligent Traffic Center. The authors thank Ogawa & Co., Ltd., Japan, for analyzing the SO2 samples and for their assistance with the data collection. The authors would like to thank Enago (www.enago.jp) for reviewing the English language.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study was approved by the institutional review board of Kansai Medical University (reference No. 1510). The children’s parents or legal guardians provided written informed consent.
Consent for publication
All of the authors have approved the manuscript and given their consent for publication.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Table S1. Definition of respiratory symptoms in questionnaire. Figure S1. The mapping of residential address. Table S2. Statistically significant differences among the SO2 concentration in study areas. Table S3. Statistically significant differences among the NO2 concentration in study areas. Table S4. Odds ratios of respiratory symptoms in realtion to personal and environmental factors. Table S5. Comparison of prevalence of respiratory symptoms among children by residential areas
About this article
Cite this article
Enkh-Undraa, D., Kanda, S., Shima, M. et al. Coal burning-derived SO2 and traffic-derived NO2 are associated with persistent cough and current wheezing symptoms among schoolchildren in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. Environ Health Prev Med 24, 66 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12199-019-0817-5
- Air pollution
- SO2 and NO2
- Respiratory symptoms