Skip to main content

Table 4 Comparison of two FFQs with 12-day-weighed food record and FFQ1 with FFQ2 for energy-adjusted food-group intakes, based on cross-classification by quintile (%) in men and women

From: Reproducibility and validity of food group intake in a short food frequency questionnaire for the middle-aged Japanese population

  

Men (n = 143)

  

Women (n = 145)

 
 

FFQ1 vs FFQ2

DR vs FFQ1

DR vs FFQ2

FFQ1 vs FFQ2

DR vs FFQ1

DR vs FFQ2

 

Same category

Same and

Extremecategory

Same category

Same and

Extremecategory

Same category

Same and

Extremecategory

Same category

Same and

Extremecategory

Same category

Same and

Extremecategory

Same category

Same and

Extremecategory

 

adjacent

adjacent

adjacent

adjacent

adjacent

adjacent

 

category

category

category

category

category

category

Rice

41

90

0

35

75

0

35

78

2

43

86

0

37

76

1

39

77

1

Bread

45

87

1

40

86

1

41

83

1

48

89

0

39

83

1

40

82

1

Noodles

42

78

1

31

71

1

31

73

1

39

81

0

28

61

5

33

71

2

Potatoes

32

70

3

23

58

6

20

56

5

38

72

0

23

64

2

28

62

3

Soybean products

43

85

1

29

59

1

25

66

2

46

79

1

28

65

2

30

66

3

Green vegetables

41

76

1

25

65

2

28

66

3

36

80

1

22

67

3

34

67

3

Other vegetables

34

71

2

28

64

3

20

61

6

41

74

1

21

57

4

26

59

6

Fruit

49

83

1

39

73

2

38

78

1

38

83

1

31

72

2

34

72

3

Mushrooms

36

75

3

27

59

6

32

64

6

41

79

1

23

65

3

31

60

6

Seaweeds

31

71

4

28

66

6

22

69

6

32

70

3

19

61

7

27

63

6

Fish

35

80

1

28

59

4

36

73

2

49

81

1

34

68

0

31

72

0

Meat

42

78

3

22

59

2

27

63

3

40

80

1

27

65

3

27

64

5

Eggs

50

87

0

29

65

1

30

63

2

50

79

0

27

65

3

30

72

3

Milk

51

90

1

43

85

0

50

87

0

61

92

0

39

75

1

39

79

1

Oils

36

76

1

23

63

4

26

67

3

35

75

1

27

63

5

35

68

6

Confectionery

42

81

1

28

67

1

29

63

2

34

69

3

28

60

8

30

66

3

Green tea

51

85

1

39

78

1

48

83

1

54

86

1

39

80

1

41

79

1

Coffee

45

90

1

34

72

1

36

76

1

62

90

1

32

70

2

36

77

1

Alcoholic beverages

55

94

0

39

78

0

34

78

0

54

90

0

46

86

1

39

81

1

Soybean paste

45

86

1

40

76

1

40

75

1

43

81

2

35

77

1

40

81

1

Median

42

81

1

29

67

1

31

69

2

41

80

1

28

65

2

33

71

3

Range

(31–55)

(70–94)

(0–4)

(22–43)

(58–86)

(0–6)

(20–50)

(56–87)

(0–6)

(32–62)

(69–92)

(0–3)

(19–46)

(57–86)

(0–8)

(26–41)

(59–82)

(0–6)

  1. The residual method was performed to adjust the energy intake. FFQ: 47-item short food frequency questionnaire, DR: four non-consecutive 3-day weighed dietary records at intervals of 3 months (12 days)